In the last lesson you followed Lake Geneva's recovery. Cutting phosphate brought total phosphorus down from almost 90 micrograms per litre in 1979 to 15.6 in the 2025 CIPEL report, and the algal blooms became much less frequent. It looks like a success story.
Yet in spring 2025, CIPEL's measurements in the deepest water of the lake, between 250 and 309 metres down, found only 2.7 to 3.2 mg of dissolved oxygen per litre. Every reading was below the 4 mg/L minimum that Swiss water protection law sets for lakes. A cleaned-up lake is still running short of oxygen at the bottom.
This lesson explains why. First you will widen your view of what pollutes water, beyond the sewage, fertiliser and plastic you met earlier. Then you will meet blooms that do not wait to die before they kill, because they make poisons. Finally you will see why low-oxygen water is becoming more common, in Lake Geneva and far beyond it. Three of the places in this lesson are in Switzerland, shown on the map.
![Swiss places in this lesson [Base map: Natural Earth, public domain]](attachment:9e7be1b2-f806-406b-a100-e22642abe040:swiss-places-map.png)
Swiss places in this lesson [Base map: Natural Earth, public domain]
Source: CIPEL, Bulletin limnologique, spring 2025
<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />
4.4.9 There is a wide range of pollutants that can be found in water.
These pollutants may include organic matter (for example, sewage), dissolved substances (for example, tributyltin, an endocrine-disrupting chemical), persistent chemicals that become biomagnified (for example, PCBs), plastics and heat energy.
</aside>
In water.4.1 you sorted pollution by its source: sewage, farm run-off, industry and so on. Now you sort it by what the pollutant is, because that decides how it does harm and how long it lasts. The course names five kinds.
Organic matter, such as sewage, food waste and the de-icing glycol from Geneva Airport, is not usually poisonous. The harm comes as it rots. Decomposers feed on it and use up dissolved oxygen as they respire, so fish and invertebrates suffocate. It breaks down quickly, in days or weeks, and that fast breakdown is exactly what strips the oxygen.
Plastics you met in water.4.1. They break into smaller pieces but stay as plastic for decades or centuries, and microplastics carry other toxins into food chains.
The other three kinds, dissolved substances, persistent chemicals and heat energy, are new, and each has a real example below.
Ships and boats grow a crust of barnacles, weed and slime that slows them down. From the 1960s many hulls were painted with antifouling paint containing tributyltin (TBT), a tin compound that kills anything settling on the hull. The paint slowly releases TBT into the water, where it dissolves, travels with the current and settles into harbour mud, where it lingers.
TBT is an endocrine-disrupting chemical: it interferes with the hormone systems of animals, and it does so at tiny concentrations. Its best-known victim is the dog whelk, a small sea snail of rocky shores. Female dog whelks exposed to TBT grew male sex organs, a condition called imposex, and could no longer breed. In the 1980s and 1990s whole populations disappeared from parts of the south coast of England.
TBT was then progressively restricted, and in 2008 a global ban on organotin antifouling paints on ships, agreed through the International Maritime Organization in 2001, came into force. The dog whelks came back. A survey of eleven mainland sites between Poole and Selsey found seven recolonised by 2007 to 2008. Sites close to busy ports recovered least: they had either not been recolonised or still held small populations showing imposex.
Source: Bray et al. (2011), Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the UK · Source: International Maritime Organization, AFS Convention
Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) are industrial chemicals once used in electrical equipment such as transformers, and in paints and sealants. Their manufacture has been banned for decades, but they are persistent: they do not break down, they dissolve in fat rather than water, and so they build up inside animals (bioaccumulation) and become more concentrated at each step up a food chain (biomagnification).
Lake Geneva shows both. In December 2008 the cantonal chemists of Vaud, Valais and Geneva, alongside the French authorities on the other shore, banned the sale of char (omble chevalier) longer than 39 cm. Larger fish could contain PCBs above the levels recommended by the World Health Organization. Because PCBs collect in fat, older and therefore larger fish carry more, and the study found a direct link between a fish's size and its PCB content. The contamination was diffuse: it did not depend on where in the lake the fish was caught.
In 2015, after CIPEL analyses, the same authorities also banned the sale of lake trout longer than 54 cm. Perch, pike and féra were not affected.
Source: Canton of Vaud, 16 December 2008 · Source: Canton of Geneva, 30 October 2015
Heat energy counts as a pollutant too. Power stations and factories take in river water to cool their machinery and release it warmer. This is thermal pollution. Warm water holds less dissolved oxygen than cold water, and it raises the metabolic rate of fish and invertebrates, so they need more oxygen just as less is available. Cold-water fish such as trout are the first to suffer. Unlike a chemical, heat leaves the river once the warm discharge stops, as the water mixes and loses heat to the air.
Switzerland's Beznau nuclear power plant cools itself with water from the river Aare and returns it downstream. A limit of 25°C applies to the Aare below the plant. On 29 June 2025, during a heatwave, the river reached that limit. Under a ruling from the Swiss Federal Office of Energy, the operator Axpo cut both reactors to about half power, then shut them down completely on 1 and 2 July 2025 to stop the river warming further and to protect its plants and animals.
Source: Axpo, 30 June 2025 · Source: Axpo, 3 July 2025
Complete the table below for the five kinds of pollutant, using the examples above.
| Kind of pollutant | Named example | How it harms living things | Does it break down quickly? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Organic matter | |||
| Dissolved substance | |||
| Persistent chemical | |||
| Plastics | |||
| Heat energy |
<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />
4.4.10 Algal blooms may produce toxins that threaten the health of humans and other animals.
Harmful algal blooms (HABs) contain a variety of organisms, including cyanobacteria, protists, algae and dinoflagellates. A small number of these organisms produce potentially fatal toxins. In freshwater, cyanotoxins are the most common toxins. Within the HABs that occur along coastlines, dinoflagellates produce different toxins, including a neurotoxin; these may be red in colour. Consider one example from freshwater and one from marine water.
</aside>