<aside> π
Working without your teacher today
Last lesson you saw that the countries fishing north-east Atlantic mackerel could not agree how to share the catch, so year after year the quotas they set added up to far more than the scientists advised. You also saw why it is risky to fish at or above the maximum sustainable yield (MSY).
This lesson asks three questions. Can a fish stock that has been overfished come back, and who has to work together for that to happen? Who controls the sea, and what happens in the parts of the ocean that no country controls? And should seals, whales and dolphins be hunted at all? By the end you should be able to explain how one overfished species recovered, distinguish between an exclusive economic zone and the high seas, explain why selling fishing rights raises questions of fairness, and discuss the hunting of a marine mammal from at least two contrasting perspectives.
<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />
4.3.14 Species that have been overexploited may recover with cooperation between governments, the fishing industry, consumers and other interest groups, including NGOs, wholesale fishery markets and local supermarkets.
Consider the perspective of each group of stakeholders and how differences can be resolved. Measures that help to restore stocks include temporary fishing bans, limits to fishing licences, prevention of bycatch and information to help consumers choose species that are not being harvested unsustainably.
</aside>
An overfished stock can recover, but only if fishing pressure stays low for long enough for the fish to grow, breed and rebuild their numbers. That rarely happens because one group decides it should. Each stakeholder group wants something different:
Measures that help a stock recover include:
None of these works if one group ignores it. A quota means little if boats land fish illegally, and a label means little if nobody can check where the fish came from.
<aside> π‘
Keep this list in mind
In the case study below, look for what each of the five stakeholder groups did, or had to accept. You will need it for the table in question 3.
</aside>

A large Atlantic bluefin tuna lying on the deck of a fishing boat.
Source: NOAA FishWatch, via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).
The Atlantic bluefin tuna is a large, fast predator. The eastern stock feeds across the Atlantic and breeds in the Mediterranean. It is managed by ICCAT, the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas, whose member governments agree the catch limits.
Decline. Demand for bluefin rose around the world from the 1980s, and more than 90% of the bluefin caught in European waters was exported to Japan. In 1996 catches were estimated at 50,000 to 61,000 tonnes. ICCAT set its first catch limit in 1998, at 30,000 to 33,000 tonnes a year, but the limit was not respected: more than 50,000 tonnes a year are estimated to have been caught between 1998 and 2008. By 2006 the stock was close to collapse.
Pressure from outside. In 2010 Monaco, backed by conservation groups, proposed a ban on international trade in Atlantic bluefin under CITES, the treaty that controls trade in endangered species. It was rejected by 68 votes to 20, with 30 abstentions, which left the job of saving the stock to ICCAT.
The recovery plan. From 2007 ICCAT ran a 15-year recovery plan. Its member governments agreed to:
From 2016 bluefin has been tracked with an electronic catch document that records who caught each fish, where and when, as it passes from the boat to the market. Fish without a valid document cannot be traded legally, so markets and importers became part of the controls. Today the producers' organisation in Sète, France's main bluefin port, says it campaigns to keep the controls strong so that the overfishing of the past does not return.
The result. By 2017 ICCAT's scientists judged the stock "no longer overfished". In 2021 the IUCN moved the Atlantic bluefin from Endangered to Least Concern on its Red List, crediting quotas that were enforced and the fight against illegal fishing. The Marine Conservation Society's Good Fish Guide moved bluefin from red ("fish to avoid") to amber for the first time, and in 2020 a small French Mediterranean fishery using hooks and lines was certified as sustainable by the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC), whose blue label shoppers can look for. ICCAT has raised the catch limit step by step, and in November 2025 agreed 48,403 tonnes a year for the next three years.
Sources: MSC, recent history of bluefin tuna; TRAFFIC, March 2010; Pew, April 2016; IUCN, September 2021; Marine Conservation Society; European Commission, November 2025.
euronews: Europe's bluefin tuna made a remarkable comeback. Will it last? [30 September 2025]
euronews: Europe's bluefin tuna made a remarkable comeback. Will it last? [30 September 2025]
1. Describe two ways that scientists in the video monitor the bluefin stock. Then explain why the report ends with a warning.
2. Between 1998 and 2008, more than 50,000 tonnes of bluefin a year were caught against a catch limit of about 30,000 tonnes. Using these two figures, calculate by what percentage the catch exceeded the limit. Show your working.
3. Use the case study and the video to complete the table. For each stakeholder group, say what it wanted and what it did, or had to accept, during the bluefin recovery.
| Stakeholder group | What it wanted | What it did, or had to accept, in the recovery |
|---|---|---|
| Governments (through ICCAT) | ||
| Fishing industry | ||
| Consumers | ||
| NGOs | ||
| Wholesale markets and supermarkets |
<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />
4.3.15 According to the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), coastal states have an exclusive economic zone stretching 370 km out to sea, within which the state's government can regulate fishing. Almost 60% of the ocean is the high seas outside these coastal zones, with limited intergovernmental regulation.
There is an equity and justice issue when countries sell access to their fishing zones rather than managing it for local people. The UN has developed and signed an international treaty to protect the high seas.
</aside>
Bluefin tuna swim through the waters of many countries and out into the open ocean. So who decides the rules where? The answer comes from UNCLOS, the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, agreed in 1982. It divides the sea into zones, measured out from the coast:
Because an EEZ is measured from every coastline, even a small island gets a circle of sea 370 km wide around it, so countries made up of many scattered islands can control huge areas of ocean.
The IB guide says almost 60% of the ocean is high seas. The UN and most news reports give a figure of about two-thirds. Either way, the high seas are the largest part of the ocean, and only about 1% of them is protected.
flowchart TD
A["Coast"] --> B["Territorial sea<br>0 to 22 km"]
B --> C["Exclusive economic<br>zone, to 370 km"]
C --> D["High seas<br>beyond 370 km"]
B -.- B2["Part of the<br>country's territory"]
C -.- C2["Country controls<br>fish, oil and gas"]
D -.- D2["No single country<br>in charge"]

World map showing the exclusive economic zones of every coastal country as coloured areas around the coastlines, with the high seas left blank in the middle of the oceans.
Source: Gugganij, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0). Map drawn in 2008.
Sources: Hodder p. 368 to 369; AP News, January 2026.
4. Distinguish between an exclusive economic zone and the high seas.
5. Explain why fish stocks on the high seas are especially at risk of overexploitation.