Duplicate this page before you start, and write all your answers in your own copy.

<aside> 📝

Why this lesson matters for your essay. Two of the six titles for your own exam session, May 2027, ask about exactly the kind of knowledge you will look at today.

Title 3: In the production of knowledge, how can knowledge be reliable if it is built on assumptions? Discuss with reference to the human sciences and one other area of knowledge.

Title 6: In the pursuit of knowledge, what value is there in exploring the paradoxical or the counterintuitive? Discuss with reference to the natural sciences and one other area of knowledge.

Title 3 asks for the human sciences and one other area of knowledge. You have just finished the human sciences. Mathematics is a strong choice for the other, because its assumptions are written down at the start, as axioms.

Nothing on this page answers either title. But every case today is real, named and dated: the kind of evidence an essay needs. Look out for the 📌 marks, which show where a case connects to one of these titles. At the end, you will decide what the cases let you say.

</aside>

The human sciences unit kept asking one question: what does a study have to take for granted before it can begin? The last lesson promised that the question would matter even more in mathematics, an area of knowledge that does not study people and does not observe anything at all. Today you find out why.

flowchart LR
  A["Natural sciences<br/>How far does<br/>evidence reach?"] --> B["Human sciences<br/>What is taken<br/>for granted?"]
  B --> C["Mathematics<br/>What if nothing<br/>is observed<br/>at all?"]

This unit has two lessons, and one question runs through both of them:

Is absolute certainty attainable in mathematics?

✍️ Write here, on your own: your first answer, in one sentence, and how sure you are of it, from 0 to 100. You will come back to it at the end of the next lesson.

🏺 1. If every book vanished


Imagine that tonight every book, file and memory of mathematics disappeared, and people had to start again from nothing.

✍️ Before you read on, write here, on your own: fill in the table. Would people rebuild each statement exactly the same, differently, or are you not sure?

Statement Same, different or not sure? Why?
1. 2 + 2 = 4
2. The angles of a triangle add up to 180°.
3. The square root of 2 is about 1.41421.
4. We count in tens, and write ten as "10".
5. The letter x stands for an unknown number.

https://revise.alltheway.ing/workshops/class-ranking/embed/2TAm5DmF

When everyone has finished, your teacher will collect the class's answers. Do not read on until then.

Now some evidence.

The clay tablet YBC 7289, front and back. Yale Peabody Museum; photograph by A. Urcia, combined image by Theodor Langhorne Franklin. Public domain (CC0). Source

The clay tablet YBC 7289, front and back. Yale Peabody Museum; photograph by A. Urcia, combined image by Theodor Langhorne Franklin. Public domain (CC0). Source

This clay tablet, known as YBC 7289, was written in Mesopotamia, in what is now Iraq, between about 1800 and 1600 BCE. It is small and round, and was probably a student's exercise. It shows a square with its two diagonals.

The scribe did not count in tens, as you do, but in sixties. Along the diagonal are the numbers 1, 24, 51 and 10. In a counting system based on 60, they mean 1 + 24/60 + 51/3,600 + 10/216,000, which is about 1.41421296. The square root of 2, the length of the diagonal of a square with sides of 1, is about 1.41421356. The two agree to within about one part in two million.

David Fowler and Eleanor Robson, "Square Root Approximations in Old Babylonian Mathematics: YBC 7289 in Context," Historia Mathematica 25, no. 4 (1998): 366–78, https://doi.org/10.1006/hmat.1998.2209.