In the last lesson you asked what makes something valuable and whose interests should count, using the Rhône, Iceland's fin whales and a class vote on moral standing. Knowing that something matters still does not tell you what to do about it. This lesson looks at three ways people decide what the right action is: by asking what a good person would do, by weighing up the consequences, or by asking whose rights are at stake.
You will test each approach on a case from Switzerland: ibex hunting in Valais, a new reservoir planned beside a melting glacier in the Bernese Oberland, and a vote in Basel on rights for monkeys and apes. By the end you should be able to explain virtue ethics, consequentialist ethics and rights-based ethics, and show how each can lead to different conclusions about the same issue.
![[The three Swiss cases in this lesson. Boundaries: swisstopo, via the swiss-maps package (2026); Triftsee position: Wikipedia]](attachment:93effb0a-40c1-4ec6-93bb-d79011368bcd:lens-1-3-swiss-cases-map.png)
[The three Swiss cases in this lesson. Boundaries: swisstopo, via the swiss-maps package (2026); Triftsee position: Wikipedia]
<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />
HL.c.8 There are three major approaches of traditional ethics: virtue ethics, consequentialist (for example, utilitarian) ethics and rights-based (deontological) ethics. These ethical approaches contrast by focusing on the person’s character (virtues), the consequences of actions or the rights of the entities involved.
</aside>
Each approach looks at a different part of a decision, so each asks a different question:
Worked example: Iceland's whale hunt, June 2023. You met this case in the last lesson. On 20 June 2023 Iceland suspended its fin whale hunt after the Food and Veterinary Authority found that harpooned whales were taking too long to die under the Animal Welfare Act. One hunt lasted five hours. Here is how each approach could judge the suspension:
| Approach | Question it asks | How it could judge the suspension |
|---|---|---|
| Virtue | What would a compassionate, responsible person do? | A compassionate person would not accept an animal dying slowly over five hours, so stopping the hunt shows compassion and responsibility. The suspension was right. |
| Consequentialist | Which choice brings the most good overall? | Weigh the whales' suffering, Iceland's reputation and whale-watching tourism against lost jobs and lost exports to Japan. The answer depends on how much weight each consequence is given. |
| Rights-based | Whose rights does the action affect? | If whales have a right not to be made to suffer, slow killing violates it, so the suspension was right. But someone who stresses the whalers' right to earn a living could argue against it. |
Notice two things. Each approach starts from a different question, and none of them fixes the answer: the consequentialist and rights-based rows could point either way.
Sources: Al Jazeera, 20 June 2023.
1. Geneva celebrates with fireworks over the lake. Three people object. Identify which ethical approach each person is using, and say how you can tell.
| Statement | Approach, and how you can tell |
|---|---|
| "The noise frightens birds and pets, and the smoke dirties the air, so the harm outweighs one evening of fun." | |
| "The wildlife living by the lake has a right not to be disturbed." | |
| "A city that really cared for its lake would find a gentler way to celebrate." |
<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />
HL.c.9 Virtue ethics focuses on the character of the person doing the action. It assumes that good people will do good actions and bad people will do bad actions. It might be judged that respect, compassion and responsibility are virtuous approaches to the natural world.
</aside>
Virtue ethics judges the person rather than the act on its own. It asks what kind of person someone is, and what kind of person their actions are making them. A good person has virtues, such as honesty, courage and fairness, and the guide suggests that respect, compassion and responsibility are the virtues that matter most towards the natural world. Their opposites, such as greed, cruelty and vanity, are vices.
The Alpine ibex was hunted to extinction in Switzerland by the end of the 19th century and later brought back by reintroduction. It has recovered so well that Valais gamekeepers counted a record 7,000 ibex at the end of 2024. The canton keeps numbers down by hunting, arguing that too many ibex would damage forests and crops and compete with chamois.
![[A male Alpine ibex at the Creux du Van in the Swiss Jura, December 2021. Males' horns keep growing throughout their lives, which is why trophy hunters want the oldest animals. Photo: Giles Laurent, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons]](attachment:def78c54-579d-49ca-a3be-e9c6534b022c:ibex-creux-du-van.jpg)
[A male Alpine ibex at the Creux du Van in the Swiss Jura, December 2021. Males' horns keep growing throughout their lives, which is why trophy hunters want the oldest animals. Photo: Giles Laurent, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons]
For many years Valais also sold permits to wealthy hunters from abroad who wanted an old male's horns as a trophy. The fee rose with horn length, up to CHF 20,000 for horns of about 110 cm, and in 2020 the canton earned about CHF 650,000 a year this way.
The animals these hunters shoot are part of the cull the canton plans anyway. So what bothers people? For a virtue ethicist the question is not only whether one more ibex dies, but what paying to kill an animal for its horns says about the character of the person doing it.
Sources: swissinfo, 29 August 2020; swissinfo, 12 December 2024; blue News, 2025.
2. Identify one virtue and one vice that a virtue ethicist might see in a hunter who pays CHF 25,000 to shoot an old male ibex for its horns.
3. The ibex population is at a record high and the animal would be culled anyway. Explain why a virtue ethicist could still object to trophy hunting.
4. Two walkers each pick the same wild flower on a mountain path, with exactly the same effect on the plant. One picks it to sell to tourists. The other picks it to press in a notebook and remember the walk. Explain why a virtue ethicist might judge the two walkers differently when a consequentialist would not.
<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />
HL.c.10 Consequentialist ethics is the view that the consequences of an action determine the morality of the action. In consequentialist ethics, actions with good consequences are good actions, and actions with bad consequences are bad actions. Morally good actions are those that result in the greatest common good. The intention of the action does not affect the morality of the action; it is simply a matter of the outcome.
</aside>