🎯 Context


In the last lesson you mapped five positions on wolves in the Swiss Alps, from the sheep farmer to the conservation charity, and saw how each grows from a belief about the relationship between humans and nature. Underneath those positions sit two quieter questions. What makes something valuable? And whose interests should count when we decide what to do?

This lesson answers both. You will follow one river, the Rhône, from its glacier in the Valais through Lake Geneva and on to the Mediterranean, and one animal, the fin whale. By the end you should be able to explain instrumental and intrinsic value, show why they are not exclusive, and explain what it means for something to have moral standing.

Instrumental value


<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />

HL.c.4 Instrumental value is the usefulness an entity has for humans. The value may come from providing goods (for example, food and water), services (for example, decomposers processing waste) or opportunities for human development (for example, knowledge or creative inspiration).

</aside>

Something has instrumental value when it is useful to people. It is valued as a means to an end: "good for something". The guide sorts that usefulness into three kinds:

The Rhône rises at the Rhône Glacier in the Valais, flows into Lake Geneva at its eastern end, leaves the lake at Geneva and runs through France to the Mediterranean below Arles.

[The Rhône drainage basin. The river rises at the far eastern end of the Valais, where the map uses its Upper Valais name, Rotten. Map: NordNordWest, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0]

[The Rhône drainage basin. The river rises at the far eastern end of the Valais, where the map uses its Upper Valais name, Rotten. Map: NordNordWest, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0]

Along the way the river and the lake are useful to millions of people. Lake Geneva supplies 80 to 90% of the drinking water used in the canton of Geneva, and Geneva's hydroelectric plants, most of them on the Rhône, meet about a quarter of the canton's electricity needs.

Instrumental value depends on what people need and what they can do. The fall of the Rhône at Verbois was worth nothing as electricity until turbines were built to use it.

Sources: État de Genève, eaux de surface; État de Genève, force hydraulique et barrages.

1. Fill in the table. Decide whether each use of the Rhône and Lake Geneva is a good, a service or an opportunity for human development.

Use Good, service or opportunity?
Lake water treated and piped to homes in Geneva
Perch caught by the lake's fishers and served in lakeside restaurants
Bacteria in the Rhône breaking down organic matter left in treated wastewater from Geneva's sewage works
Reed beds where the Rhône enters the lake, trapping sediment and filtering the water
Scientists measuring temperature and oxygen from a research platform anchored in the lake off Pully
Mary Shelley beginning to write Frankenstein in 1816 while staying beside the lake at Cologny

2. Explain why the instrumental value of the Rhône could change even if the river itself stayed exactly the same.

Intrinsic value


<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />

HL.c.5 Intrinsic value is the value one may attach to something simply for what it is. For example, non-living objects, such as landscapes, may be valued because they are wild, culturally significant or beautiful. Living organisms may be valued because, like humans, they have parts, processes and behaviours organized to accomplish survival and reproduction, so we should respect their ongoing existence and well-being.

</aside>

Something has intrinsic value when it is valued for what it is, not for what it does for us: "good in itself". A person who values a glacier intrinsically would say it matters even if no one ever drank its meltwater, used its power or even saw it.

The guide gives two different reasons for valuing things in this way:

The Rhône Glacier, at Gletsch in the Valais, is where the river begins. An ice grotto has been cut into it for visitors every year since 1870. Each summer local people wrap the ice around the grotto in white fleece blankets, which slow its melting and help keep the grotto open.

Intrinsic value cannot be measured in money. That makes it hard to weigh against instrumental value, which often can be, and it is one reason environmental decisions are so contested.

Sources: Marketplace, 29 September 2015; Sierra, January 2019.

3. Distinguish between the reason the guide gives for valuing a landscape such as the Rhône Glacier intrinsically and the reason it gives for valuing a living organism such as a trout.

4. The blankets help keep the ice grotto open for visitors, which is a reason based on instrumental value. Suggest how someone could defend the blankets using intrinsic value instead.

Both at once: whales


<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />

HL.c.6 The concepts of instrumental and intrinsic value are not exclusive. For example, whales may be considered to have intrinsic value from their aesthetic appeal; they may be considered to have instrumental value as a tourist attraction.

</aside>

Case study: fin whales and Iceland's last whaling company


The fin whale is the second-largest animal on Earth and is listed as vulnerable worldwide. People value whales in many ways at once.

Putting a price on a whale. In 2019, economists at the International Monetary Fund (IMF) estimated that each great whale stores on average about 33 tonnes of carbon dioxide over its life. Counting that carbon together with the fish and tourism whales support, they valued each great whale at more than US$2 million, and the world's roughly 1.3 million great whales at over US$1 trillion. Before industrial whaling there were an estimated 4 to 5 million.

Hunting whales. Iceland, Japan and Norway are the only countries to have allowed commercial whaling in recent years, despite a worldwide pause on it that took effect in 1986. Iceland's only whaling company, Hvalur, hunts fin whales from a station in Hvalfjörður, north of Reykjavík, and sells the meat mainly to Japan. On the north coast, Húsavík is known as Iceland's whale-watching capital.

[Iceland's whaling station at Hvalfjörður and the whale-watching town of Húsavík. Base map: NordNordWest, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0; places added]

[Iceland's whaling station at Hvalfjörður and the whale-watching town of Húsavík. Base map: NordNordWest, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0; places added]

Sources: IMF, Chami et al., 2019; Al Jazeera, 20 June 2023; SeafoodSource, 2026; The Star (Reuters), 14 September 2026; Iceland Review, 11 September 2026; National Geographic, Húsavík.

[4 September 2023]

[4 September 2023]

5. Watch the clip. Note one way the whale is described as useful to people, and one reason given for opposing the hunt.

6. Fill in the table. For each group, say what it values about a fin whale and whether that value is instrumental, intrinsic or both.

Group What it values about a fin whale Instrumental, intrinsic or both?
Hvalur, the whaling company
A whale-watching company in Húsavík
The IMF economists
A campaigner who wants the hunt banned because whales suffer