🎯 Context


In Foundation you met worldviews and environmental value systems, and you placed people on a spectrum running from ecocentric through anthropocentric to technocentric, using the way Swiss voters split on four environmental votes. That lesson was about where people stand. This lesson asks how people decide what is right or wrong in the way we treat the environment. That question belongs to ethics.

As an HL student you will look at every topic through three extra lenses: environmental law, environmental economics and environmental ethics. Ethics comes first because the other two lenses keep returning to it. By the end of this lesson you should be able to explain what ethics and environmental ethics are, and how different beliefs about the relationship between humans and nature lead to different ethical frameworks.

What is ethics?


<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />

HL.c.1 Ethics is the branch of philosophy that focuses on moral principles and what behaviours are right and wrong. Students should be exposed to a variety of ethical examples from across the world. Details of these are not required.

</aside>

Ethics is the part of philosophy that asks how we ought to act, and why. An ethical claim says that something is right or wrong, good or bad, fair or unfair. It is different from three other kinds of statement you will meet in this course:

Every culture has thought about right and wrong, and many traditions include duties towards the natural world. Five examples from across the world are shown in the table below. You do not need the details of any of them, but notice how differently they place humans in relation to nature.

1. Sort each statement in the table below. Write ethical, factual, legal or preference in the middle column, and say how you can tell in the right-hand column.

Statement Type How can you tell?
Switzerland had about 350 wolves in 2025.
It is wrong to kill wolf cubs.
I would rather hike where there are no wolves.
Since December 2023, cantons may cull wolf packs before they cause damage.
Farmers deserve to be compensated when wolves kill their animals.

2. Explain why the statement "It is legal, so it must be right" is not a sound ethical argument.

Tradition Where it comes from Core idea about humans and nature
Ubuntu Southern Africa "A person is a person through other people." Right action strengthens relationships within a community, and some writers extend that community to the wider living world.
Kaitiakitanga Māori, Aotearoa New Zealand People act as guardians (kaitiaki) of land, water and living things that they are related to through ancestry. New Zealand's Resource Management Act 1991 requires decision-makers to have particular regard to it.
Buen vivir (sumak kawsay) Andean South America A good life means living in balance with the community and with nature, rather than pursuing ever more consumption. Ecuador wrote it into its constitution in 2008.
Ahimsa (non-harm) Jain and Buddhist thought, India Avoid causing harm to any living being. Jains apply this so strictly that some monks sweep the path ahead of them to avoid treading on insects.
Stewardship Jewish, Christian and Islamic thought Humans are given a special role on Earth, but as trustees who must care for it rather than owners who may use it as they please.

The five traditions do not agree. Some see humans as one member of a wider family of living things; others give humans a special role with special duties. Keep that difference in mind: it is the key to the rest of this lesson.

3. Choose two traditions from the table. Identify one way they agree and one way they differ in how they see the place of humans in nature.

Where environmental ethics came from


<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />

HL.c.2 Environmental ethics is a branch of ethical philosophy that addresses environmental issues. This branch of ethics arose in the 1960s and 1970s when environmental issues and awareness became more prevalent. There was a concern that Western ethical traditions focused on interpersonal actions and relationships and were inadequate to address the moral status of non-human or non-living environmental entities.

</aside>

For most of its history, Western ethics was about how people should treat other people. Lying, stealing and harming others were wrong because of their effect on humans. Wolves, rivers and mountains only mattered if what happened to them affected someone.

In the 1960s, books such as Silent Spring (1962) and images such as Earthrise (1968), which you met in Foundation, made environmental damage hard to ignore. Philosophers began to ask whether our duties stop at other humans. Environmental ethics grew out of that question: it asks how humans ought to treat the environment, including non-human and non-living things.

Two arguments from this period are still widely discussed:

4. Outline why some thinkers argued that traditional Western ethics could not deal with environmental issues.

5. Distinguish between shallow ecology and deep ecology.

6. Identify one non-living part of the environment around Geneva that environmental ethics might ask us to consider. Suggest why someone might think it matters in its own right.

Beliefs about nature lead to ethical frameworks


<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />

HL.c.3 A variety of ethical frameworks and conflicting ethical values emerge from differing fundamental beliefs concerning the relationship between humans and nature. If one believes the human species is of no significant difference to the rest of nature, this might lead to a more ecocentric position that all components of nature have intrinsic and equal rights, and ethical judgements can be made on that basis. If one believes that the human species is part of nature, but has special responsibility of stewardship towards it, that may influence ethical judgements in favour of a compassionate, respectful, good steward. If one believes that nature is quite separate and is there to serve human needs, then one may be likely to embrace a more extreme anthropocentric or technocentric worldview and simply consider what brings the greatest good to the greatest number of people.

</aside>

An ethical framework is a set of moral principles used to judge how people should act towards nature. Frameworks do not appear from nowhere. Each one grows from a deeper belief about what humans are in relation to the rest of nature, and because those beliefs differ, the frameworks often conflict.

The table below sets the three beliefs in the guide alongside the spectrum you used in Foundation. Notice that stewardship sits between the two ends: the steward sees humans as part of nature, but with a special duty to look after it for others and for future generations.

7. Explain how the belief that humans are part of nature but have a special responsibility towards it leads to different judgements from the belief that nature exists to serve human needs. Use one example.

8. Using what you learned about anthropocentrism in Foundation, suggest why stewardship is placed between ecocentric and anthropocentric rather than at one end of the spectrum.

Belief about humans and nature The framework it tends to lead to Where it sits on the Foundation spectrum
Humans are no different from the rest of nature All parts of nature have equal rights, and judgements are made on that basis Ecocentric
Humans are part of nature but have a special responsibility towards it Act as a compassionate, respectful, good steward Between ecocentric and anthropocentric
Nature is separate from humans and is there to serve human needs Do whatever brings the greatest good to the greatest number of people Anthropocentric or technocentric

Applying it: wolves in Switzerland