Over the last few lessons you have seen what a warmer climate is already doing to oceans, reefs, forests and mountains, and to the societies that depend on them. This lesson goes back to the cause and asks a different question: once the planet starts to warm, what decides how far the warming goes?
In atmosphere.2.1 you saw that, for 800,000 years, carbon dioxide and temperature have risen and fallen together. In atmosphere.1.2 you were told that water vapour would come back in 6.2, because of the way it adds to warming. And in foundation.2.3 you met feedback loops: negative feedback counteracts a change, while positive feedback amplifies it, as when dusty snow on the Swiss glaciers melted sooner and exposed darker ice.
A puzzle. The energy arriving from the Sun rises and falls by less than 0.1% over its 11-year cycle, and it has shown no upward trend since 1980. Yet in 2024 the Earth's average surface temperature was about 1.55 °C above the 1850 to 1900 average [Source]. The answer lies in the balance between the energy the Earth gains and the energy it loses, and in the feedback loops that change that balance.
Task 0
You will come back to these predictions in Phase 2.
<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />
6.2.7 Systems diagrams and models can be used to represent cause and effect of climate change with feedback loops, either positive or negative, and changes in the global energy balance. Include solar radiation variations, terrestrial albedo changes and methane gas release with their associated feedback loops.
</aside>
Energy in, energy out. The Earth gains energy from sunlight and loses energy as infrared radiation to space. In atmosphere.1.2 you saw that about 29% of the sunlight arriving at the top of the atmosphere is reflected straight back to space, and the rest is absorbed by the air and the surface. The warmed surface emits infrared, and greenhouse gases slow its escape.
When the energy absorbed equals the energy lost, the global average temperature stays steady. This is the global energy balance. It is the same idea as the steady-state equilibrium you met with Daisyworld: energy keeps flowing in and out, but the inputs balance the outputs.
Three things can change the balance, and the guide names one example of each:
flowchart TD
A["Sunlight arriving<br>at the Earth"] --> B["Reflected to<br>space (albedo)"]
A --> C["Absorbed by the<br>surface and air"]
C --> D["Earth warms and<br>emits infrared"]
D --> E["Infrared escapes<br>to space"]
D --> F["Greenhouse gases<br>absorb infrared"]
F --> G["Some re-emitted<br>down to surface"]
G --> C
The Earth is out of balance. Since 2000, NASA's CERES instruments on satellites have measured the energy arriving at and leaving the Earth. Together with floats that measure the heat stored in the oceans, they show that the imbalance roughly doubled between 2005 and 2019 [Sour ce]. The World Meteorological Organization (WMO) reports that the imbalance reached a new high in 2025, and that the heat stored in the oceans was the highest in 66 years of measurement [Source]. As long as more energy comes in than goes out, the planet keeps warming.
A built-in brake. In atmosphere.1.2 you saw that the warmer an object is, the more radiation it gives off. So as the Earth warms, it emits more infrared to space, which works against the warming. This is a negative feedback, and it is the strongest feedback in the climate system [Source]. On its own, it would bring the Earth back into balance at a slightly higher temperature. The rest of this lesson looks at the feedbacks that push the other way.
Task 1
The guide names three causes of change in the energy balance: solar radiation, albedo and methane. Each one can start a change, and feedback loops decide how big that change becomes.
In Davos, in Graubünden, the Physikalisch-Meteorologisches Observatorium Davos has studied the energy arriving from the Sun since 1907. In 1971 the WMO made it the World Radiation Center, so it is now known as PMOD/WRC. It looks after the group of instruments that sets the world standard for measuring sunlight [Source]. Davos is about 290 km from Geneva in a straight line.

Map built for this lesson from Natural Earth data (public domain).
Measuring the Sun from the ground is difficult, because the atmosphere absorbs and reflects part of the sunlight. So since 1988, instruments built in Davos have also flown in space. One of them, VIRGO, has measured the Sun from the SOHO spacecraft since it was launched in December 1995 [Source]. At the top of the atmosphere, each square metre facing the Sun receives about 1,361 watts (W/m²) [Source].
The graph puts satellite measurements of the Sun's energy since 1980 above the global temperature over the same period.

Sun: yearly averages of the NRL observational composite of satellite measurements, via LASP LISIRD, 1980 to 2019. Temperature: HadCRUT5, Met Office Hadley Centre and University of East Anglia, 1980 to 2024, shown as the difference from the 1850 to 1900 average. Chart made for this lesson.
What the graph shows. The Sun's energy rises and falls with an 11-year cycle, as the number of sunspots changes. Between its lowest and highest years it changes by about 1.2 W/m², less than 0.1%, and each peak is about the same height as the one before. Between 1980 and 2024, the global temperature rose by about 1 °C. So the Sun is not the cause of the recent warming.
Solar variations still matter. A change in the sunlight arriving is a change in the energy balance, so it can start warming or cooling. Whether that change stays small or grows depends on the feedback loops that follow.
Task 2
In foundation.2.3 you saw albedo at work on the Swiss glaciers. The same loop runs on a far larger scale over the Arctic Ocean. Thick sea ice covered in snow reflects up to 90% of the sunlight that reaches it. The open ocean has an albedo of about 0.06: it reflects only about 6% and absorbs the rest [Source].
Each September, at the end of the summer melt, the sea ice shrinks to its smallest area of the year.

The Arctic sea ice minimum on 10 September 2025: 4.60 million km². The yellow line shows the average minimum for 1981 to 2010. Image: NASA's Scientific Visualization Studio, using NASA and NSIDC data [Source].
The 2025 minimum tied with 2008 as the 10th lowest since satellite records began in 1978, and it was far below the 1981 to 2010 average [Source].
The loop. Warming melts sea ice. Melting replaces bright ice with dark water, so the albedo of the Arctic falls. The dark water absorbs more sunlight, which warms the ocean and the air above it, which melts more ice. Feedbacks like this one help to explain why, since 1979, the Arctic has warmed nearly four times as fast as the world as a whole [Source].
Task 3
Task 4.2 Draw your answer in the drawing tool below, as you would in the on-screen exam. Use a box for each step and arrows to join them, and label the loop as positive or negative feedback. When you have finished, take a screenshot and paste it under the tool.