🎯 Context


Last lesson you saw climate change at two scales: global impacts such as sea-level rise and ocean acidification, and local ones such as coral bleaching on the Great Barrier Reef and desertification in south-east Spain. This lesson asks two further questions. What happens to an ecosystem when the climate it depends on moves? And why do some ecosystems cope with change better than others?

In Topic 2 you saw that as the climate warms, biomes shift towards the poles and up mountainsides, and that the species at the top of a mountain have nowhere left to go. This lesson looks at that process close to home, in Valais, and then at what makes an ecosystem resilient.

Task 0

  1. Predict whether each ecosystem will lose, gain or both as the climate warms. Give a reason for each.

You will come back to your predictions at the end of the lesson.

Phase 1: Biome shifts and the regions that gain


<aside> <img src="/icons/leaf_green.svg" alt="/icons/leaf_green.svg" width="40px" />

6.2.5 Climate change impacts ecosystems at a variety of scales, from local to global and affects the resilience of ecosystems and leads to biome shifts. Include alteration to individual ecosystems, such as coral bleaching and desertification as local impacts, and changes to ocean circulation and sea-level rise as global impacts. Consider a range of climate change impacts on regions where natural productivity may increase, and consider the factors that have an impact on the resilience of an ecosystem, particularly biodiversity. Use local real-world examples to emphasize the changes.

</aside>

Valais, upstream of Lake Geneva, shows both directions of change in one valley.

Local example: One valley, two directions in Valais


The valley floor: pine gives way to oak. The floor of the Rhône valley in Valais is unusually dry for Switzerland, because the mountains on both sides block much of the rain. The Pfynwald, between Sierre and Leuk, gets about 575 mm of precipitation a year, far less than Geneva, and is the largest continuous pine forest in Switzerland [Source]. The lower slopes of the valley are covered by forests of Scots pine.

valais-map.png

Map: © swisstopo, national map 1:1 million [Source]. The Pfynwald lies between Sierre and Leuk.

Scientists from the Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research (WSL) compared forest plots in Valais, from the valley floor up to 1,600 m, in 1983/85 and again in 2002/03. In twenty years, the number of Scots pines in the canopy fell by 17.5%, while the number of pubescent oaks, a tree that copes better with drought, rose by 160.7%. Most pines died below 1,000 m, and more of them died in the years after dry summers. Under the trees, young oaks outnumbered young pines by about five to one. The scientists named drought, made worse by rising temperatures, as the main driver. Changes in how people use the forest also play a part: animals are no longer grazed there, which lets young broadleaf trees grow [Source].

Watering a forest. Since 2003, WSL has watered half of a group of plots in the Pfynwald, giving them about 600 mm of extra water a year. The watered pines grew wider tree rings and longer needles, and more of them survived. But even with extra water, it was young broadleaf trees, not young pines, that took hold [Source].

pfynwald-pines.jpg

Dried-out Scots pines in the Pfynwald, August 2025. Photo: Arkelin, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0 [Source].

Pine and oak forest are both temperate forest, so this is not a change of biome. But it is the same process that drives biome shifts: as the climate changes, species suited to the new conditions take over from the ones that were there before.

Above the treeline: a region that gains. High in the mountains, plant growth is limited by cold and by the short season between snowmelt and the first frosts. Warming lengthens that season. Satellite images from 1984 to 2021 show that 77% of the Alps above the treeline became greener, meaning plants there are growing more, while less than 1% became browner [Source]. On 302 mountain summits across Europe, the number of plant species increased five times as fast between 2007 and 2016 as between 1957 and 1966, as plants from lower down move uphill. On Piz Linard in Graubünden (3,410 m), botanists found 1 plant species in 1835 and 16 in a recent survey [Source].

The same process has winners and losers. Productivity rises where cold used to hold growth back, as it does on the northern edge of the boreal forest you met in Topic 2. But the cold-adapted plants that live only near the summits are pushed into an ever smaller area at the top.

Task 1

  1. Describe how the forests on the lower slopes of Valais changed between 1983/85 and 2002/03. Use figures.

  2. Explain how the Pfynwald experiment shows that a shortage of water is harming the pines.

  3. Explain why the productivity of plants above the treeline in the Alps is increasing.

Watch the whole clip. It was filmed on Mount Kenya, near the equator in East Africa.

[24 December 2025]

[24 December 2025]

  1. The reporter says climate scientists call what is happening on Mount Kenya an "escalator to extinction". Explain what this means for the plants and animals near the summit.

Phase 2: Resilience: why some ecosystems cope better


In Topic 1 you saw that resilience is the ability of a system to resist damage and to recover from, or adapt to, a disturbance without crossing a tipping point. Climate change is a disturbance that keeps on growing, so resilience decides which ecosystems hold on. These factors make a difference:

You met this graph last lesson. It shows the highest heat stress reached each year at two stations on the Great Barrier Reef. Above 8 °C-weeks there is a risk that heat-sensitive corals die.

gbr-heat-stress.png

Data: NOAA Coral Reef Watch, regional virtual stations, downloaded 5 November 2026 [Source].

Task 2

  1. Using the Great Barrier Reef graph, explain why the reef's resilience is falling.

Case study: Spruce plantations in Central Europe


Norway spruce is native to mountains and cold northern forests. It was planted widely outside its natural range across Central Europe, because it grows fast, its seedlings were plentiful, and its timber is excellent [Source]. Many of these forests were planted as plantations of a single species, with all the trees the same age [Source].

Drought, storms and beetles. The summers of 2018 to 2020 were hot and dry across Central Europe. Storms, drought and outbreaks of bark beetles, which breed under the bark of spruce, killed spruce on a huge scale. From January 2018 to April 2021, Germany lost tree cover on 501,000 ha, almost 5% of its forest. The worst-hit areas included the Harz mountains [Source]. Between 2012 and 2022 the area of spruce forest in Germany fell by 461,000 ha, or 16.8%, and in the Harz large areas were left bare [Source].

harz-map.png

Map: Thoroe, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0, using OpenStreetMap data (2017) [Source]. The Brocken is the highest point of the Harz.

harz-dead-spruce.jpg

Dead spruce on the Brocken, Harz, August 2020. Photo: Hajotthu, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0 [Source].

In Switzerland, the volume of spruce wood attacked by bark beetles reached 1,489,151 m³ in 2019, the highest since 2003. By 2025 it had fallen to an estimated 414,835 m³ [Source]. The Federal Office for the Environment says that the growing diversity of tree species and structures in Swiss forests is improving their resilience to climate change [Source].

Why mixing helps. A pest that specialises in one tree species spreads easily through a forest made of nothing else. In a mixed forest, its host trees are scattered among others it cannot use, and if one species dies, the others keep the forest standing. Research shows that mixed forests resist specialist insect pests better than single-species ones. Mixing is not a guarantee: how well a mixed forest copes with drought depends on which species are in it [Source].

Model: spruce or mixed? The model below is a forest of 1,600 trees seen from above. A drought weakens spruce so that it can no longer push out bark beetles with resin, and beetles spread from infested trees to the spruce around them. It is a model: it shows a pattern, not measurements from a real forest.

https://ess.alltheway.ing/simulations/embed/forest-resilience

Task 3

  1. Set the drought to Moderate, the gap between droughts to Just one, the beetles to Next tree and the planting to Tree by tree. Run the forest at 100% spruce, then at 30% spruce mixed with oak. Then switch the planting to In blocks and run 30% spruce with oak again. Record the lowest canopy cover and the number of trees killed by beetles each time.
  2. Use your results to explain why a spruce plantation is less resilient to climate change than a mixed forest.
  3. Explain why more spruce died when the forest was planted in blocks, even though the share of spruce was the same.
  4. Set 30% spruce, planted tree by tree, and a Severe drought. Run the forest mixed with oak, then with beech, then with beech and oak. Use your results to evaluate the claim that high biodiversity always protects an ecosystem from climate change.
  5. Go back to 100% spruce and a Moderate drought. Change the gap between droughts from Just one to 10, 5 and 3 years. Explain how the gap between droughts affects the resilience of the forest, and link your answer to the Great Barrier Reef graph.

Task 4 Complete the table for the four ecosystems. For example, for the mountain ecosystems of Mount Kenya in the clip: the main impact is that the zones of vegetation are moving upslope and the highest zone is shrinking; summit species are losers; and the loss of most of the forest belt to farming has reduced resilience. Then go back to your predictions in Task 0: which were right, and which ecosystem surprised you?

| --- | --- | --- | --- |

Common misconceptions